Pieter Bruegel the Elder — painter of peasants and seasons
Two men from the city, dressed as peasants, slip in among the guests at a village wedding. They bring gifts like everyone else, pass themselves off as relatives of the bride, eat, drink and watch. One is a merchant, Hans Franckert. The other is a painter named Pieter Bruegel, and nothing escapes him: the way people dance, the way they eat, the way they court.
The story comes from Karel van Mander, who in 1604, thirty-five years after Bruegel’s death, published the first major biography of the Netherlandish painters. It long fixed the image of a painter of ordinary people, their feasts and their follies. He was nicknamed “Peasant Bruegel,” and was even credited, wrongly, with peasant birth.
His friends saw him differently. The geographer Abraham Ortelius, one of the most famous scholars in Antwerp, wrote that Bruegel had painted things that cannot be painted, and that his pictures always said more than they showed. Pieter Bruegel left only about forty paintings. They were enough to change the history of landscape and of the painting of everyday life.
A painter from Breda
His life begins in a haze. No one knows the exact date of his birth, usually placed around 1525, or even the place: probably Breda, in Brabant, or somewhere nearby. Van Mander mentions a village called Breughel that supposedly gave him his name, but it has never been identified with certainty.
According to Van Mander, the young man trained in Antwerp with Pieter Coecke van Aelst, a painter and tapestry designer. His master’s wife, Mayken Verhulst, was a miniaturist herself, and the Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium believe she may have taught him the rudiments of that painstaking art. Van Mander adds a tender detail: the apprentice often carried the little daughter of the house in his arms, the girl he would marry some fifteen years later.
Pieter Coecke died in 1550. The following year, a “Peeter Brueghels” was admitted as a master to the Guild of Saint Luke, the Antwerp painters’ guild: the first firm date in his life. That same year he received his first known commission, a monochrome painting for an altarpiece that the glovers’ guild intended for Saint Rumbold’s Cathedral in Mechelen.
Antwerp was then one of the leading ports and largest markets in Europe, and a center of printing where publishers were looking for draftsmen. Bruegel did not stay long. Like many young painters from the North, he set off for Italy.
Crossing the Alps
The journey took him through France to Rome, where some of his drawings are dated 1553, and probably farther south. A View of the Bay of Naples, in Rome’s Galleria Doria Pamphilj, recalls that descent toward the Mediterranean. Its attribution was long debated; research carried out for the great Vienna exhibition of 2018 confirmed it.
In Rome, Bruegel crossed paths with Giulio Clovio, the most celebrated miniaturist of his day. Clovio’s inventory lists several works by Bruegel, including a small Tower of Babel painted on ivory. It is lost, but the subject would never leave him.
What struck him most was not antiquity but the mountains. Crossing the Alps, Van Mander writes, he “swallowed all the mountains and rocks,” only to spit them back out, once home, onto his canvases and panels.
Back in Antwerp, he drew vast Alpine landscapes, with plunging valleys, torrents and peaks as far as the eye can see. The National Gallery of Art in Washington owns several of these sheets, including a landscape with the penitent Saint Jerome dated 1553. Around 1555–56, the publisher Hieronymus Cock turned them into a series of prints, the Large Landscapes. Those mountains would return, transplanted into the flat Flemish countryside, all the way to his last paintings.
The prints of Antwerp
On his return, Bruegel became one of the regular suppliers of Cock, the city’s leading print publisher, whose shop bore the sign “At the Four Winds.” Between 1555 and 1563 he delivered more than forty designs for engravings: landscapes, allegories, moral scenes. Until the early 1560s he was known above all as a draftsman. Today he is credited with some sixty drawings and about eighty prints, against roughly forty paintings.
The public was mad about the devilish fantasies of Hieronymus Bosch, who had died in 1516, and Cock knew what sold. When he published Big Fish Eat Little Fish in 1557, after a drawing by Bruegel, he went so far as to attribute it to Bosch. Later prints carried the words “Bruegel inventor,” but the lineage was plain to see. Van Mander reports that the young painter was nicknamed “Pieter the Droll” for his devilish fantasies and comic scenes, and his contemporaries saw him as Bosch’s true heir.
It was through these prints, issued in large numbers, that his name first spread across Europe.
Proverbs, games and carnival
In the late 1550s, Bruegel turned more and more to painting. He also changed the spelling of his name: the guild records had called him Brueghels, but he now signed BRVEGEL, without the h, while his sons would go back to Brueghel. His paintings of these years are whole worlds, crowded with hundreds of figures that have to be read one by one.
Netherlandish Proverbs, painted in 1559 and now in Berlin, gathers more than a hundred proverbs and sayings in a single village for the first time. People fill in the well after the calf has drowned, carry daylight out in baskets, and a woman throws a blue cloak over her husband’s shoulders, a sign that she is cheating on him. A globe hung upside down gave the picture its other old title, The World Upside Down. Behind the fun, the Berlin museum reads a catalog of human sins and deceptions.
The Fight Between Carnival and Lent, painted the same year, sets the camp of feasting against the camp of fasting in a packed town square. Research in Vienna has revealed what the picture was hiding. X-rays show a corpse in a cart pulled by an old woman, and another body lying on the ground. According to Sabine Pénot, a curator at the Kunsthistorisches Museum, it was not Bruegel who made them disappear but a later hand, probably in the seventeenth or eighteenth century. Bruegel himself had first drawn a cross on a baker’s peel, which he replaced with two fish as he painted.
Then came Children’s Games, in 1560, and darker visions. In The Triumph of Death, at the Prado, an army of skeletons led by Death on a reddish horse drives humanity toward an enormous coffin. Only a pair of lovers, in the lower right corner, seems to notice nothing. For Alejandro Vergara, head of Flemish and Northern European painting at the Prado, Bruegel blends Bosch’s medieval tradition with a tradition of classical origin to produce terror through satire. The Fall of the Rebel Angels, painted in 1562 and now in Brussels, belongs to the same vein.
These are not mere genre scenes. They put human wisdom, folly and vanity into pictures, at a time when the Low Countries were torn by religious conflict.
Brussels, the great years
In 1563, Bruegel married Mayken Coecke, his former master’s daughter, in the church of Notre-Dame de la Chapelle in Brussels. According to Van Mander, it was the bride’s mother, Mayken Verhulst, then living in the city, who set a condition: he had to leave Antwerp and move there. Brussels was the seat of government of the Low Countries, and wealthy art lovers were not in short supply. The couple would have two sons, Pieter, born in 1564, and Jan, in 1568.
From then on, Bruegel supplied hardly any designs for prints and devoted himself to painting. It was in Brussels that he painted his masterpieces.
The Tower of Babel
That same year he signed The Tower of Babel, now in Vienna. A colossal tower, its top piercing the clouds, rises above a tiny Flemish harbor town. Its tiers of arches recall the Colosseum, which Bruegel may have seen in Rome. In the lower left, King Nimrod, who is not named in the biblical account, inspects the building site with his retinue, while the stonemasons kneel before him.
The Kunsthistorisches Museum stresses the almost encyclopedic precision of the picture: materials arriving through the port, cranes, scaffolding on the unfinished brick foundations. Bruegel anchors the tower in a rock to give it a sense of balance, yet the building warps as it rises. The panel itself has suffered: at some unknown date, it was sawn down along the top and right edges.
Around 1568, Bruegel took up the subject again on a smaller panel, now at the Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen in Rotterdam, where more than a thousand workers swarm over the site. The two Towers of Babel were brought together for the first time only in 2018, in Vienna.
The Hunters in the Snow
In 1565, Bruegel painted a series on the times of the year for the Antwerp merchant Niclaes Jongelinck, who would own sixteen of his pictures; the Met’s Harvesters belongs to it. The most famous of the five surviving panels is the winter scene.
Three hunters trudge back to the village, followed by their dogs, their backs bent. Their catch is meager: a single fox, slung over one man’s shoulder. On the left, outside an inn, a family busies itself around a fire to singe a pig, a motif that books of hours had long used to illustrate the month of December. The inn sign, half torn from its bracket, reads “dit is inden Hert,” “At the Deer”: the Vienna museum sees it as an ironic jab at the hunters’ empty-handed return.
Below, the valley opens onto frozen ponds where little figures skate. The colors are reduced to white, blue-green and brown, and they are enough to make the cold felt. This landscape exists nowhere: Bruegel combined Alpine peaks, brought back from his journey, with the architecture of Flemish villages.
The Peasant Wedding
Around 1567–68, Bruegel painted his great peasant scenes, in which the figures, now on a large scale, fill the whole height of the panel. The Peasant Wedding, in Vienna, takes us into a barn where the party is in full swing. The bride sits enthroned before a green hanging, beneath a paper crown. The groom is nowhere to be found: according to the Kunsthistorisches Museum, Flemish custom kept him away from the feast.
In the foreground, two men carry in the dishes on a door taken off its hinges, a server pours beer into jugs, and a child sits on the floor, eating. For the museum, this apparent snapshot is in fact carefully composed. The Peasant Dance, painted at the same time, shows a village festival to the sound of the bagpipes.
These peasant pictures are not the work of a man of the people. Bruegel moved among scholars: the geographer Abraham Ortelius, author of the first modern atlas, and the printer Christophe Plantin were among his friends. The people who bought his peasants were wealthy merchants and humanists, not villagers.
The subject lost in the crowd
Bruegel liked to hide what matters most. In The Procession to Calvary, of 1564, he takes up a Netherlandish tradition reaching back to Jan van Eyck: the road to Calvary told as a long procession from Jerusalem to Golgotha. Christ, fallen under the weight of the cross, sits at the center of the picture, and yet you have to look for him. He vanishes among several hundred figures, soldiers, onlookers, peddlers, all streaming toward the place of execution. On the right, clouds gather over Golgotha. It is Bruegel’s largest known panel, and the largest landscape in all of early Netherlandish painting.
The Census at Bethlehem, painted in 1566 and now in Brussels, moves the Gospel to a Flemish village in the snow. Villagers line up outside the inn where people are counted and taxes collected, children slide on the ice, a pig is slaughtered outside a house. It takes a moment to spot, in the foreground, a man with a saw on his shoulder leading a donkey: he is Joseph, and the pregnant Mary rides on the animal. The Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium point out that Bruegel painted “alla prima,” laying colors over layers that were still wet.
The Massacre of the Innocents, in the British Royal Collection, met a stranger fate. Bruegel shows armored horsemen invading a snowbound village and killing the newborns, like Herod’s soldiers in the Gospel of Matthew. Very early, before 1621, and probably while the picture belonged to Emperor Rudolf II, the slaughtered children were painted over with bundles, food and animals. Van Mander described a massacre in 1604; an inventory of 1621 speaks of a village being plundered. The shadows of the small bodies can still be seen beneath the overpaint. Before it was altered, one soldier’s banner bore five gold crosses on a white ground, the arms of Jerusalem, a title claimed by Philip II of Spain.
Then there is Landscape with the Fall of Icarus, one of the most famous pictures in the Brussels museums. A plowman cuts his furrow, a shepherd gazes at the sky, a fisherman casts his line. In a corner, two legs thrash in the sea: Icarus has just fallen, and no one cares. W. H. Auden drew one of his best-known poems from it in 1938, “Musée des Beaux Arts.” The picture is probably not by Bruegel’s own hand. Bought by the museum in 1912 as a copy, then long regarded as an original, it is now considered by the researchers Dominique Allart and Christina Currie to be a copy of a lost work by the master.
The final years
The years 1566 and 1567 were terrible ones for the Low Countries. In the summer of 1566, a wave of destruction of religious images, the Iconoclastic Fury, swept through the churches. The following year the Duke of Alba arrived in Brussels in the name of the king of Spain to restore order, and ruled by terror.
Bruegel’s last paintings, from 1568, are often enigmatic. The Parable of the Blind, in Naples, shows six blind men dragging one another toward the ditch. The Magpie on the Gallows, in Darmstadt, sets a gibbet in the middle of a radiant landscape where peasants dance. Van Mander reports that the painter left this picture to his wife, and that the magpie stood for gossips, whom he would gladly have seen hanged.
Pieter Bruegel died in Brussels on September 9, 1569, at about forty. Van Mander tells how, on his deathbed, he asked his wife to burn some of his drawings, whose inscriptions were too biting, out of remorse or for fear they might get her into trouble. He was buried in Notre-Dame de la Chapelle, the church where he had married.
A few years later, Abraham Ortelius devoted a page to his friend in his album amicorum, the “book of friends” in which scholars and artists left him a text or a drawing; it is now at Pembroke College, Cambridge. He wrote that Bruegel had painted many things that cannot be painted, and that in all his works there is always more to understand than what is painted: plus semper quam pingitur.
A dynasty and a legend
His sons were still small children when he died. According to Van Mander, it was their grandmother, Mayken Verhulst, who taught them drawing and watercolor. Pieter the Younger, later nicknamed “Hell Brueghel,” spent his life reproducing his father’s compositions. Winter Landscape with Skaters and a Bird Trap, painted in 1565 and now in Brussels, is known through more than a hundred copies, about fifty of them by his hand.
Jan, known as “Velvet Brueghel,” became one of the great flower painters of his time and a friend of Rubens. At his request, around 1613–15, Rubens painted Christ Giving the Keys to Saint Peter to adorn Pieter Bruegel’s tomb; the original is now in Berlin, and a copy still hangs in the church. With their descendants, the family produced painters over four generations.
If Vienna owns twelve of his paintings today, nearly a third of those that survive, it is thanks to the Habsburgs. Archduke Ernst acquired some in Brussels as early as 1594, and Emperor Rudolf II gathered others in Prague. In 2018, the Kunsthistorisches Museum brought together 29 of the roughly 40 surviving paintings for the largest exhibition ever devoted to the artist, the most successful in the museum’s history. It drew on a research program launched in 2012 with support from the Getty Foundation, whose infrared and X-ray images can be explored online at Inside Bruegel. Among other things, you learn there that of the twelve Vienna panels, only The Procession to Calvary has kept its original format.
Since the twentieth century, Bruegel has become a reference far beyond painting. Andrei Tarkovsky had the seasons series reproduced for the library of the space station in Solaris (1972), where the camera lingers over The Hunters in the Snow, and he quoted the picture again in Mirror (1975). Lars von Trier used it in Melancholia (2011). The English novelist Michael Frayn, for his part, imagined in Headlong (1999), shortlisted for the Booker Prize, an academic convinced he has found the series’ missing panel.
Where to see Pieter Bruegel’s work
In Vienna and the rest of Europe
Any Bruegel pilgrimage leads to Vienna. The Kunsthistorisches Museum gathers most of its twelve paintings in a single room, Gallery X, from The Tower of Babel to The Peasant Wedding, by way of The Hunters in the Snow, The Procession to Calvary and Children’s Games. The Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, in Brussels, hold the second-largest collection, with The Fall of the Rebel Angels, The Census at Bethlehem, Winter Landscape with Skaters and a Bird Trap and Landscape with the Fall of Icarus.
Elsewhere, almost every picture is worth a detour: Berlin for Netherlandish Proverbs, Madrid for The Triumph of Death, Naples for The Parable of the Blind, Rotterdam for the smaller Tower of Babel, Darmstadt for The Magpie on the Gallows, Antwerp for Dulle Griet at the Museum Mayer van den Bergh, Prague for Haymaking at the Lobkowicz Palace, and Rome for the View of the Bay of Naples. The Massacre of the Innocents belongs to the British Royal Collection, which displays it at Windsor Castle.
In Paris
The Louvre owns just one painting by Bruegel, and it is tiny: 18.5 by 21.5 centimeters (about 7¼ by 8½ inches). Painted in 1568, The Beggars shows five disabled beggars moving on crutches across a courtyard. Their carnival headgear, a cardboard crown, a paper cap, a beret, seems to dress them up as a king, a soldier or a burgher. On the back of the panel, an inscription in Flemish, reconstructed by the museum, wishes them courage and good fortune. The painting entered the Louvre as a gift in 1892.
In the United States
In New York, the Met shows The Harvesters, the only painting from the seasons series to have left Europe. Then you have to cross the country. The Detroit Institute of Arts owns The Wedding Dance, signed and dated 1566, whose purchase in 1930 was hailed as a sensational discovery. In San Diego, the Timken Museum of Art shows The Parable of the Sower, from 1557, one of the painter’s earliest dated pictures, in which the sower fills only a corner of a vast landscape of river and mountains. Finally, the National Gallery of Art in Washington holds many drawings and prints, available in open access on its website, including the only etching he made himself, The Rabbit Hunt.
Further Reading
Institutional Documentation
- Pieter Bruegel the Elder (ca. 1525–1569) — The Metropolitan Museum of Art — an essay on his career, from prints to great paintings.
- The Best of Bruegel — Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna — the largest collection of Bruegel paintings in the world.
- Inside Bruegel — Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna — the twelve Vienna paintings in very high resolution, in infrared and in X-ray.
See also on Hors Cadre
- The Harvesters — summer according to Bruegel — the panel from the seasons series that hangs in New York.
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art — what to see, hours, tickets — hours, tickets and highlights, from Bruegel’s harvest to Van Gogh’s cypresses.
— M