The Harvesters — summer according to Bruegel
Pieter Bruegel the Elder — painter of peasants and seasons →It is hot on this summer day. The wheat stands tall and thick, and men cut it down with wide sweeps of the scythe. A woman, bent double, binds a sheaf. In the shade of a pear tree, others have set down their tools: they share bread, cheese and porridge eaten straight from the bowl, while one man sleeps, sprawled full length on the ground. In the distance the countryside opens onto a village, a church and a bay where ships sail by.
Painted by Pieter Bruegel the Elder in 1565, The Harvesters is one of the great treasures of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. It is also the only painting from his famous series of the seasons to have crossed the Atlantic: the others remained in Europe, in Vienna and Prague.
There is no saint here, no hero, no biblical episode. Just a working day at the hottest moment of the year. For a picture of this size, in 1565, that was close to a revolution.
Six seasons for a dining room
The story begins in Antwerp, then one of the richest cities in Europe. The merchant Niclaes Jongelinck, a major collector, owned sixteen paintings by Bruegel. For his country house just outside the city, he commissioned a series devoted to the times of the year.
Bruegel did not divide the year into four seasons but into six, roughly following the rhythm of farm work; an inventory of 1595 describes the set as “six panels of the twelve months of the year.” According to the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, The Gloomy Day stands for early spring, Haymaking for early summer, The Harvesters for late summer, which the Met places in July and August, The Return of the Herd for autumn and The Hunters in the Snow for winter. The late spring panel seems to have been lost in the seventeenth century.
In the spring of 1566, Jongelinck hung the series between the windows of his newly decorated dining room. The panels probably covered all four walls, perhaps with statues of the planets between them. Of the five that survive, three are now at the Kunsthistorisches Museum, Haymaking is at the Lobkowicz Palace in Prague, and The Harvesters is in New York.
The theme came from a long tradition: the “labors of the months” that illustrated the calendars of medieval books of hours, such as the famous Très Riches Heures du Duc de Berry, painted by the Limbourg brothers and now at the Musée Condé in Chantilly, near Paris. But Bruegel changed the scale. What once fit on a page became a vast landscape.
A diagonal of wheat
The composition is built on a great diagonal. On the left rises a wall of golden wheat, which the reapers cut into with their scythes. A narrow passage cut through the stalks leads down toward the foreground, where a man brings back jugs. On the right, the harvested field gives way to rows of sheaves, then to the resting group, then to the landscape.
The figures take up only a small part of the picture: the countryside, the light and the heat dominate. The yellow of the wheat answers the green of the trees and the blue of the horizon. In the triangular silhouette of the woman bent over her sheaf, the Met sees a figure that melts into the landscape, as if labor and land were one.
Farther off, other peasants pick apples. At the upper left, a bluish disk floats in the sky, and the Met admits it does not know what it represents. It is not the harvest moon, the full moon closest to the autumnal equinox, which comes later in the season; and a full moon that high in the sky would mean it was night, not noon. Nor is it an eclipse: the disk would be black, ringed by a bright corona, the landscape would darken, and the peasants would have reason for alarm. Perhaps, the museum suggests, it is simply the distant sun, veiled by the haze of a late-summer midday.
The midday meal
This is the heart of the picture, and one of the liveliest passages in all of Flemish painting. Sitting in a circle at the foot of the pear tree, the harvesters eat the everyday fare of the countryside: bread, cheese and grain porridge. They drink, eat and catch their breath. Beside them, the sleeper has not waited for the meal to end.
How should we read these peasants? The Flemish Art Collection stresses direct observation: Bruegel paints rural life without idealizing it. The Met offers a nuance: his peasants are painted with sympathy, but their world is harmonious and abundant, and the harshness of farm labor stays in the background. After all, the picture was made for the dining room of a wealthy city dweller who liked to look out at the countryside from his country house.
In the middle distance
The picture fills with people the longer you explore it. At the center, boys play a cruel game of the time, throwing sticks at a tethered rooster until it is dead. In a pond shaded by trees, monks have shed their robes to bathe. In the bay, tall ships wait, ready to carry the harvest to distant ports.
Landscape for its own sake
According to Met curator Adam Eaker, The Harvesters is one of the works that gave birth to landscape as an independent genre. Until then, landscape had mostly served as a backdrop for a religious or mythological scene. Here, it is the subject itself.
This landscape, for that matter, exists nowhere. Bruegel grafts details observed from life onto a view seen from a promontory that could never have existed in such flat country, the Met points out. Nothing is left to chance: beneath the paint, the underdrawing sets out the main lines of the composition and certain details, down to the position of the birds in the sky.
For the Met, the series is hardly conceivable without an earlier stage: the vast panoramas Bruegel drew after his journey to Italy, engraved in 1555–56 as the Large Landscapes series. The photographer Laura McPhee, invited by the museum to talk about the painting, even sees it as an anticipation of photography: it is as if you were standing outside with a large-format view camera, watching the world unfold.
The Flemish Art Collection calls the series a turning point in Western art: the religious pretext for landscape fades away in favor of a new humanism, attentive to ordinary people and to the world as it is.
A painting for writers
The Harvesters has its writers, too. In 1950, Ernest Hemingway visited the Met, found the painting’s gallery closed and complained to the journalist Lillian Ross: “I sure miss the good Bruegel. It’s the great one, of the harvesters.” A decade or so later, William Carlos Williams devoted “The Corn Harvest” to it, one of the poems in Pictures from Brueghel, the collection that won him a posthumous Pulitzer Prize for Poetry in 1963. The poet sees the whole composition organized around the young reaper asleep at its center, “the resting center” of a workaday world.
Patrick Bringley, a guard at the Met for ten years before he wrote a book about the job, put it simply in an essay for the museum: no picture rewarded his attention as consistently.
From the imperial court to New York
The painting’s journey reads like a novel. Jongelinck died in 1570, and the series passed to another Antwerp owner; in 1594 the city of Antwerp bought it for 1,400 florins and presented it to Archduke Ernst of Austria, the new governor of the Netherlands. It then went to Emperor Rudolf II in Prague, then to Archduke Leopold Wilhelm, and joined the imperial collections in Vienna.
In 1809, when Napoleon’s armies occupied Vienna, The Harvesters left the imperial collections for those of General Count Antoine-François Andréossy. In 1816 it sold at auction in Paris for just over 90 francs, under the wrong date: the catalogue described it as dated 1546. It then belonged to a Paris collector, Jacques Doucet, and to Paul Jean Cels in Brussels, who sold it to the Metropolitan Museum in 1919.
The price was a pittance. The art market had all but collapsed during World War I, and the picture lay hidden under grime, yellowed varnish and unsightly retouching along the cracks where the boards meet. The Met’s curator of paintings, Bryson Burroughs, took a chance that it was an original Bruegel, a gamble that cost the museum very little. He was right.
Seeing The Harvesters in New York
New York is the only place in the United States to see a painting from the series. The Harvesters hangs at the Met in Gallery 638, on the second floor. The oak panel measures 45 7/8 by 62 7/8 inches (116.5 × 159.5 cm) for the original painted surface; strips of wood were added later at the top, bottom and right. The signature and date, at lower right, are now almost illegible.
To see the rest of the series, you will need to travel to Vienna, where the Kunsthistorisches Museum holds three of the panels, and to Prague, where the Lobkowicz Palace displays Haymaking.
Further Reading
Institutional Documentation
- The Harvesters — The Metropolitan Museum of Art — the museum’s record and downloadable image.
- The Seasons à la Bruegel — Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna — the series of six seasons and the Vienna panels.
- Patrick Bringley on The Harvesters — The Metropolitan Museum of Art — the painting seen by a former Met guard, from Hemingway to the details in the middle distance.
- Photo Credit : The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
See also on Hors Cadre
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art — what to see, hours, tickets — how to plan your visit, from Bruegel to the American Wing.
- Pieter Bruegel the Elder — painter of peasants and seasons — his life, from Antwerp to Brussels.
— M