Masterpiece

The Death of Socrates — hemlock, virtue and the Terror

Jacques-Louis David — from the Oath of the Horatii to Napoleon's Coronation →
Date
1787
Medium
Oil on canvas
Dimensions
129,5 × 196,2 cm
Location
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

In a prison of bare stone walls, an old man with an athlete’s torso sits on his bed. He is still talking. One hand rises, forefinger pointing to the sky; the other reaches for the cup of poison held out to him, without even a glance at it. Around him his friends weep, wring their hands, hide their faces. He alone is calm.

Painted by Jacques-Louis David in 1787, The Death of Socrates is one of the most famous pictures at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. When Thomas Jefferson, then the American minister to France, saw it at the Paris Salon, he wrote to his friend the painter John Trumbull: “The best thing is the Death of Socrates by David, and a superb one it is.”

The painting honors a man who chose death over renouncing his principles. Seven years later, the man who had commissioned it went to the guillotine during the Terror, while the painter sat among those who governed France.


Athens, 399 BCE

Socrates was over seventy when an Athenian court sentenced him to death for impiety and for corrupting the young. The sentence could not be carried out at once: every year Athens sent a sacred ship to Delos, and no one could be put to death before it returned. Socrates waited in prison and refused to escape. The account of his last day comes to us from Plato, in a dialogue called the Phaedo.

That morning his friends found him just released from his chains. His wife, Xanthippe, was taken home with their child. Socrates spent the day discussing the immortality of the soul. At sunset the servant of the Eleven, the magistrates in charge of the prisons, came to tell him the hour had come, then burst into tears and turned away. Socrates drank the hemlock without a tremor, walked about until his legs grew heavy, and lay down as the cold crept through his body. His last words were for his friend Crito: “We owe a cock to Asclepius. Pay the debt, and do not forget it.”

The dialogue closes with a tribute: of all the men of his time, Socrates was “the best, the wisest and the most just.” Another detail of the text matters for the painting: Plato was not there. “Plato, I believe, was ill,” the dialogue’s narrator explains.


The suspended gesture

David chose the most charged instant of the story: the moment the poison passes from one hand to another. The Louvre stresses how new that choice was. Earlier painters had shown Socrates dying, the hemlock already drunk; David, like his rival Peyron the same year, stops the image just before, as the philosopher finishes speaking and is about to take the cup.

Socrates fills the center of the canvas, draped in white, bare-chested. His body, powerful and smooth, is nothing like an old man’s; his face is modeled on ancient busts of the philosopher. The young man holding out the cup turns his face away, unable to look at him. Crito, bearded, seated close by, grips his teacher’s thigh as if to hold him back. On the right, the disciples collapse against the wall. In the background at left, through an archway, Socrates’s family climbs a staircase and leaves.

The raised finger lends itself to two readings. For the Met, Socrates points to the heavens, absorbed in his argument for the immortality of the soul. For the Louvre, this orator’s gesture, borrowed from the figure of Plato in Raphael’s School of Athens, points to the law, which justifies his execution and rises above it. The Paris museum also notes that the scene gathers thirteen figures around a cup, as in the Last Supper: religious devotion carried over into the secular world. Diderot had already called Socrates a martyr.

And at the foot of the bed, his back to the scene, sits Plato. David painted him as an old man, though he was young in 399 and absent that day, with a scroll, a pen and an inkwell beside him. The Met explains it simply: he is there because he wrote the Phaedo. The perspective lines of the architecture even converge on his head.


Reading the Phaedo in paint

The picture rewards anyone who knows the text. On the floor in the foreground lies an open iron shackle, and Socrates’s ankle still shows a faint red mark: in the dialogue he has just been freed from his chains and rubs his leg. On the bed, a lyre recalls a passage in which one of his friends, Simmias, compares the soul to the tuning of an instrument.

David signed twice: his initials appear as if carved into the stone block where Plato sits, and his name appears beneath Crito. He also consulted scholars of antiquity so that costumes and objects would be accurate; tradition names among them the Oratorian priest Jean-Félicissime Adry.


Five years in the making

David was thinking about the subject as early as 1782, shortly after returning from Rome. A first drawing, signed and dated, already shows the prisoner on his bed, surrounded by friends. The commission came in 1786 from the Trudaines, two brothers from a dynasty of senior royal administrators, whose liberal salon David attended. The Met credits the elder, Charles Louis Trudaine de Montigny, a young councilor in the Paris Parlement; the Louvre names the younger, Charles-Michel Trudaine de la Sablière. The fee is put at 10,000 livres.

A study from that time, acquired by the Met in 2015, shows the painter at work. The cupbearer moves to the left, the disciples on the right grow from four to six, and Crito no longer holds a book but grips Socrates’s thigh. Corrections cluster around the hands and legs: the whole picture turns on these gestures. The poet André Chénier, a friend of the Trudaines, has sometimes been credited with the idea for Socrates’s.


The Salon of 1787

The painting was shown at the Salon of 1787, in the Louvre, and its success was immediate. The showdown had been anticipated: Pierre Peyron, David’s chief rival, was painting the same subject for Louis XVI, on a commission placed in the king’s name by the comte d’Angiviller. Short of time, Peyron sent only a reduced version, which arrived late, and the comparison went decisively in David’s favor; Peyron’s full-size canvas was not shown until 1789. The smaller picture sent to the Salon is now in the Statens Museum for Kunst in Copenhagen.

The praise crossed the Channel. A famous verdict is credited sometimes to Joshua Reynolds, sometimes to the London print publisher John Boydell, writing to Reynolds: the picture was “the greatest effort of art since the Sistine Chapel and the stanze of Raphael,” a work that “would have done honour to Athens at the time of Pericles.”

Here David consolidated the Neoclassical style he had launched two years earlier with The Oath of the Horatii, now in the Louvre: figures lined up like an ancient relief, cool, crisp light, clear colors, nothing to distract. For Keith Christiansen, curator emeritus at the Met, this manner was as radical in its day as Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon would be 120 years later.

Its message, too, arrived at the right moment: a lone man resisting unjust authority for the sake of his principles. Two years later, the French Revolution broke out.


Hemlock in Thermidor

David became one of the Revolution’s leading artists. Elected to the National Convention, he voted to execute Louis XVI, then joined the Committee of General Security, which ran the political police during the Terror.

Trudaine de Montigny, meanwhile, was imprisoned. He appealed to David, in vain. On July 26, 1794, he was guillotined, and his brother met the same fate; their friend André Chénier had died on the scaffold the day before. That very evening, at the Jacobin Club, a threatened Robespierre compared himself to Socrates and declared that he would drink the hemlock. David reportedly answered: “I will drink it with you.”

Two days later Robespierre was executed. David never got as far as the hemlock: arrested, he spent several months in prison, where he drew portraits of former Jacobin deputies held there like him. The great image of stoic virtue had followed the whole story, from its guillotined patron to its jailed painter.


From Paris to New York

After the Terror, the painting stayed in the family: it passed to Charles Louis Trudaine de Montigny’s widow, Louise Micault de Courbeton, who died in 1802, then to various relatives and descendants. The Metropolitan Museum bought The Death of Socrates in 1931, through the fund bequeathed by the New York collector Catharine Lorillard Wolfe. It has since acquired two of the preparatory drawings as well: the 1782 sheet and the 1786 study.

When it rehung its European paintings, the museum moved the canvas out of a vast gallery of portraits where it looked small, into a more intimate room among painters of David’s generation.

In the fall of 2025, the canvas returned to Paris for a few months. The Met lent it to the Louvre, which made it one of the centerpieces of its retrospective for the bicentennial of David’s death, from October 15, 2025, to January 26, 2026: the first major monographic exhibition devoted to the painter since 1989.


Where to see The Death of Socrates

At the Met, The Death of Socrates hangs in Gallery 634, on the second floor. The canvas measures 51 by 77 1/4 inches (129.5 × 196.2 cm). The two preparatory drawings are fragile and come out of storage only from time to time; the museum also owns the etching Peyron made of his own composition in 1790.

Elsewhere in the United States, the Princeton University Art Museum has an unfinished replica painted by David and his studio after 1787: the left side is nearly complete, lacking only the bars on the window and the decoration of a robe. The Joslyn Art Museum in Omaha, Nebraska, owns a Death of Socrates by Peyron dated 1788.

In Paris, the Louvre holds the great canvases that frame this one in David’s career, from The Oath of the Horatii to The Lictors Bring to Brutus the Bodies of His Sons, shown at the Salon of 1789.


Further Reading

Institutional Documentation

See also on Hors Cadre

— M